ASC 606 for Private Companies: Everything You Need to Know About the New Revenue Recognition Standards

For private companies, revenue recognition can be both a challenge and an opportunity. Accountants often face a labyrinth of complexity when managing mountains of contract data, so it’s no wonder many teams struggle to ensure accuracy. 

But with the right approach, revenue recognition can become a strategic advantage rather than a burden. By streamlining processes, private companies can enhance financial accuracy, improve forecasting, and build greater confidence with investors and stakeholders. 

Private companies need to comply with ASC 606, the revenue standard established by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), if they follow U.S. GAAP for financial reporting. While they were given extra time to adopt the standard and have fewer disclosure requirements than public companies, ASC 606 applies to all public, private, and nonprofit entities that enter into contracts with customers to transfer goods or services. However, private companies that do not follow GAAP (e.g., small businesses using cash accounting) may not be required to adhere to ASC 606.

Sticking to ASC 606 isn’t just about ticking compliance boxes—it’s your ticket to financial clarity and investor confidence.

In this guide, we’ll explore the essential components of ASC 606, including its five-step model, key requirements, and actionable tips for overcoming implementation challenges. Along the way, we’ll show you how compliance can unlock new opportunities for growth and success—proving that mastering revenue recognition doesn’t have to be daunting.

What Is ASC 606?

ASC 606, formally titled “Revenue from Contracts with Customers,” is an accounting standard introduced by the FASB to enhance Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). ASC 606 revenue recognition is all about globally standardizing the revenue recognition process, replacing the inconsistent and fragmented rules of ASC 605.

Differences Between ASC 605 and ASC 606

Under ASC 605, revenue recognized was often inconsistent and varied significantly by sector. In contrast, ASC 606 introduces:

• Uniformity across industries: A key aspect of ASC 606 is its alignment with the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) guidelines, ensuring that U.S. companies can maintain compliance in a global market. 
  
  
• Judgment-based approach: Unlike ASC 605, which relied heavily on industry-specific guidelines, ASC 606 introduces a judgment-based approach applicable to all sectors.
  
  
• Customer contract focus: This shift requires businesses to evaluate contracts comprehensively, focusing on contractual agreements with customers and identifying performance obligations.

These changes shift from rigid rules to a principles-based framework, offering greater flexibility while demanding higher levels of professional judgment.

The Five-Step Revenue Recognition Model

The 5 steps of revenue recognition form the foundation of ASC 606, designed to simplify and standardize revenue recognition while ensuring accuracy and transparency. 

Let’s explore each step in detail with some ASC 606 revenue recognition examples:

1. Identify the Contract With a Customer:
   1. A contract is an agreement that establishes enforceable rights and obligations between two or more parties. This includes formal agreements, oral arrangements, and implied contracts.
   2. Example: A SaaS company offering annual subscription plans with add-on customer support must document both the subscription and support as part of their customer contracts to ensure transparent revenue allocation.
      
      
2. Identify Performance Obligations in the Contract:
   1. Performance obligations are the distinct goods or services promised in a contract. Each obligation must be identified to allocate revenue accurately.
   2. Example: A construction firm providing architectural blueprints and on-site construction services must treat these as separate obligations.
      
      
3. Determine the Transaction Price:
   1. This step involves calculating the total amount a company expects to receive, accounting for discounts, rebates, and variable considerations.
   2. Example: A retailer offering bulk discounts must focus on estimating standalone selling prices for items included in bundled deals.
      
      
4. Allocate the Transaction Price to Performance Obligations:
   1. Revenue is allocated to each obligation based on its standalone value, ensuring fairness and transparency.
   2. Example: A software company bundling a license with maintenance services separates the price between the license and the ongoing service to allocate the individual selling prices to the performance obligations.
      
      
5. Recognize Revenue When (or As) Performance Obligations Are Satisfied:
   1. Revenue is recognized as obligations fulfilled at a specific point in time or over time.
   2. Example: A consulting firm working on a sixteen-month implementation project recognizes revenue incrementally as key milestones are completed (i.e., over time) instead of all at once when the entire project is completed.

Following ASC 606 isn’t just about keeping regulators happy—it’s about building financial transparency and trust. Investors, auditors, and stakeholders all want to see clean, clear numbers. And when your revenue reporting is rock solid, making smarter business decisions gets a whole lot easier.

Why ASC 606 Matters for Private Companies

The cost of non-compliance outweighs the cost to comply, but companies that fail to meet ASC 606 requirements may face increased audit scrutiny, higher compliance costs, and even delays in securing funding or closing deals. In a worst-case scenario, non-compliance can damage a company’s reputation, making it harder to attract investors, partners, and customers. Let’s break down some of the benefits for private companies that prioritize ASC 606 compliance. 

Enhanced Financial Trust & Transparency

ASC 606 ensures that revenue is reported accurately, reflecting a company’s financial position. Transparent financial statements give stakeholders, including investors, the confidence to make informed decisions. By aligning with revenue recognition GAAP and accrual accounting principles, companies establish credibility and reduce ambiguities in financial reporting. Additionally, ASC 606 promotes comparability across organizations and industries by standardizing revenue recognition practices. This consistency allows stakeholders to more easily compare financial performance across companies, enhancing decision-making processes and improving the overall transparency of financial reporting in the market.

Opportunities for Growth

Accurate financial reporting enhances trust and positions private companies as more appealing to potential investors or acquirers. By automating the traditionally complex and time-consuming revenue recognition process, companies gain the flexibility to quickly adopt new business and pricing models. 

This agility, enabled by ASC 606 automation, becomes a powerful driver of growth, allowing companies to seamlessly expand into new markets, introduce innovative product offerings, and explore diverse business models with ease.

Challenges Private Companies Face With ASC 606

Why is ASC 606 so tricky for private companies? For starters, contracts aren’t always straightforward—some have tiered pricing, bundled services, or last-minute changes. Then there’s the headache of managing all that data and making sure your tech stack can handle it. Sound familiar? You’re not alone.

Common challenges include:

• Complex contracts: Managing contracts with frequent modifications, tiered pricing, or bundled services can complicate revenue recognition practices. Private companies often struggle to accurately account for these variables while maintaining compliance.
  
  
• High Volume Data management: Processing high volumes of financial data can bog down legacy systems or stall month-end reporting procedures. Private enterprises need systems that can process vast amounts of data without sacrificing speed and accuracy.  
  
  
• Legacy systems: Outdated manual processes or rigid accounting tools lack the flexibility required for ASC 606’s structured demands. Legacy systems often struggle with the complexity introduced by modern revenue models.
  
  
• Connecting disparate sources: Revenue data spread across sales, accounting, and operations systems often creates gaps. Aligning these sources into a cohesive platform is vital for operational efficiency.
  
  
• Resource constraints: Without automation, accounting leaders often face the need to expand their teams as managing growing contract volumes, compiling data, and generating reports become increasingly time-consuming and complex.
  
  
• Technology integration: Adopting advanced tools that automate processes and streamline compliance often poses hurdles, particularly as companies need to integrate revenue accounting with other systems like the general ledger, an ERP, an order management system, a CRM, etc. Make sure your tools can seamlessly co-exist. 

Tips for Overcoming Challenges

Once you understand some of the challenges, successfully implementing ASC 606 requires preparing proactive solutions, such as:

• Investing in training: Empower your team with workshops and expert-led sessions to build internal capabilities and competency.
• Adopting automation: Leverage innovative tools tailored for ASC 606 to simplify revenue recognition and reporting.
• Collaborating across teams: Align efforts between accounting, IT, and sales to ensure accurate data consolidation and streamlined compliance.

By addressing these challenges proactively, private companies can achieve financial transparency and seamlessly align with ASC 606 requirements.

Key Differences Between Public and Private Company Compliance

Private companies benefit from specific considerations under ASC 606 designed to accommodate their unique challenges and resource constraints:

• Adoption Method: Public companies were required to adopt ASC 606 using either the full retrospective or modified retrospective approach, while private companies had more flexibility and could choose the approach that best suited their needs.
  
  
• Internal Controls and Audit Scrutiny: Public companies face stricter internal control requirements under SOX (Sarbanes-Oxley Act) and more rigorous external audits, while private companies have more flexibility and generally fewer compliance costs.
  
  
• Practical expedients: Private companies have access to additional practical expedients and relief options, such as simplified methods for estimating variable consideration, to ease the compliance burden compared to public companies.
  
  
• Disclosure Requirements: Public companies must provide more detailed disclosures, including breakdowns of revenue by category, contract balances, and significant judgments. Private companies have fewer disclosure requirements, reducing the reporting burden.

Tools and Resources for Compliancef

Platforms like RightRev can be game-changing for private companies navigating ASC 606 compliance. As an advanced revenue recognition solution, RightRev automates complex accounting processes to reduce manual workloads and enhance financial accuracy.

For example, a SaaS company can allocate revenue seamlessly across subscription tiers and bundled services using RightRev’s advanced capabilities, ensuring compliance and precision at every step.

The FASB provides essential guidelines that clarify ASC 606 requirements, empowering businesses to align operations with national and international standards. Additionally, the IASB offers complementary resources for global compliance, ensuring harmonized revenue practices across borders. 

By leveraging tools like RightRev and adhering to accounting standards codification guidelines, private companies can simplify compliance, optimize their revenue recognition practices, and confidently meet the demands of ASC 606.

Transforming Compliance Into Opportunity

Understanding and implementing ASC 606 for private companies is not just about compliance—it’s about building a foundation for financial clarity, operational efficiency, and long-term growth.

Taking proactive steps toward compliance ensures accurate financial reporting, minimizes the risk of audit challenges, and positions businesses to capitalize on growth opportunities. Private companies that align with these principles can confidently attract investors, pursue acquisitions, and maintain a competitive edge in their industries.

As a leading revenue recognition solution, RightRev simplifies the path to compliance by automating critical processes, ensuring accuracy, and reducing accounting team workloads. Request a demo of RightRev today and discover how our innovative solutions can simplify your ASC 606 compliance journey, enhance accuracy, and empower your business to achieve its financial goals.

Back to Blogs